Hon. Sunday afternoon. State Farm Stadium in Glendale, Arizona, the home of the Arizona Cardinals when football is in season. On Sunday it was a memorial service for Charlie Kirk, who was assassinated eleven days earlier at Utah Valley University. The stadium was, by police estimate, somewhere between sixty and seventy thousand people. The line to get in went around the block.

The first part was the memorial. Erika Kirk, the widow, gave a eulogy. She talked about her husband. She talked about their children. She forgave the killer in front of God and the cameras. She quoted scripture. The audience, much of it openly weeping, wept with her. That part was a memorial. I am not going to take a single shot at that part.

The second part is what we are talking about. The second part was a political rally. Stephen Miller, the deputy chief of staff for policy, came to the podium and used the language of war and vengeance. He used the phrase we will not stop coming. He named opponents by category. The Vice President spoke. Cabinet officials spoke. Commentators spoke. The President of the United States closed the program with remarks in which he called Kirk a martyr and said the country would respond to those who demonize. He did not explicitly name targets. The speakers before him had named them.

The form of a memorial service, hon, is a thing the country knows how to do. The form has a sequence. The sequence is the ministers, the family, the songs, the readings, the eulogies, the burial. The form can hold political feeling. Reagan after the Challenger, Obama at Mother Emanuel. Both of those presidents folded political feeling into the form without turning the form into a rally.

The form on Sunday started as a memorial. The form, by the third hour, had drifted into a campaign event. Both things were happening on the same stage, on the same afternoon, with the same body in the room. The widow was sitting fifteen feet from Stephen Miller when Stephen Miller delivered his lines. The lines did not fit the form.

The country, in the end, has to figure out how to mourn loud, prominent men who get shot at colleges. The country has to figure out how to mourn quiet, anonymous state legislators who get shot in their own houses. The country has to figure out how to do both, using the same form.

You ever notice how the form is the part the country forgets first.

Funny how that works.

FINAL · /100

The breakdown.

  • Factual basis Speakers, sequence, and crowd estimate are documented.
    17/25
  • Self-awareness The President added political asides to the eulogy.
    6/20
  • Staff containment The program was constructed as a public event.
    9/20
  • Recovery attempt Family members spoke first. Erika Kirk delivered an actual eulogy.
    7/15
  • Public spectacle Carried live across multiple cable networks for over four hours.
    13/20

Was this dumb enough?

Members can adjust the score. Become a member.

Underlying fact — TIME