The administration had announced, on Saturday, that the federal government was preparing to “surge” personnel into San Francisco as part of an immigration enforcement and public-order initiative similar to those underway in Chicago and Portland. The Mayor of San Francisco, Daniel Lurie, had spent the preceding weeks publicly objecting on jurisdictional and operational grounds. The Governor of California and the state Attorney General had threatened to litigate. The position of city leadership was on the public record, in writing, addressed to the White House.
On Thursday afternoon the President announced, on his social platform, that the deployment was canceled. The mechanism for the reversal, by his own description: telephone calls from the chief executive officer of Nvidia, Jensen Huang, and the chief executive officer of Salesforce, Marc Benioff. Both executives had asked, the President said, that the federal posture in San Francisco be reconsidered. The President had agreed.
It is worth attending to the sequence.
The Mayor of San Francisco, who is the elected chief executive of a city of approximately 800,000 people, had been asking. The Governor of California, who is the elected chief executive of approximately 39 million people, had been asking. The Attorney General of California had been preparing litigation. Their sustained and publicly documented opposition did not, by the President’s own account, alter the administration’s planning.
What altered the planning was a phone call from a chief executive officer whose company has a market capitalization larger than the GDP of every U.S. state but four. And a second one, from a chief executive officer whose company is the largest private employer in the city in question.
The Mayor, asked about the reversal at a press availability, was professional. He thanked the President. He thanked the executives by name. He said the city would continue to work in good faith. The phrasing was careful, because the alternative was to acknowledge, on camera, the constitutional implication of his own intervention having been ignored until the corporate intervention was not.
A serious country adjusts federal deployments in response to its elected officials, on the basis of statutory and operational analysis. It does not adjust them in response to two phone calls from billionaires.
The deployment is paused. The framework that produced it is unchanged.
Calmly documenting the decline.
The breakdown.
- Factual basis The phone calls and the resulting reversal are public.14/25
- Self-awareness The Mayor's prior outreach was on the public record.5/20
- Staff containment The decision was made and announced personally by the President.8/20
- Recovery attempt The Mayor handled the announcement professionally.6/15
- Public spectacle Front page on the West Coast wires.11/20
Was this dumb enough?
Members can adjust the score. Become a member.