The President, on Tuesday, presided over what he opened by calling “the final cabinet meeting of 2025, a year that will go down in history.” The meeting was televised. The transcript is on the record.
CNN’s running fact-check, published the same afternoon, identified false claims regarding consumer prices, foreign investment, the Department of War’s recruiting numbers, the 2020 election, public safety statistics, and the contents of the administration’s signature domestic policy bill. The list ran the length of the meeting.
A cabinet meeting is not, by tradition, a working session. It is a staged broadcast. Each department head, in turn, recites accomplishments. The President, in turn, comments. The cameras observe. The country, in theory, watches the executive branch coordinating itself.
What was on tape, on this occasion, was a sequence of statements that did not survive contemporaneous review. The Department of War’s recruiting figures, as represented at the table, did not match the Department’s own published numbers. The consumer-price claims did not match Bureau of Labor Statistics data, which the administration had, in August, fired the commissioner of, and which has since published its numbers without correction. The 2020 election claims have been adjudicated by the courts and the relevant state authorities, in some cases more than once.
In the second half of the meeting, video circulating on social media appeared to show the President with his eyes closed for several seconds at a stretch. The clip was distributed by Tuesday evening across the news services that cover this kind of footage. The White House did not comment on the footage.
A serious country, in its final cabinet meeting of the year, would expect a reckoning of the year. What was offered, on tape, was a recitation. The recitation was checked against the record, in real time, and the record disagreed.
Calmly documenting the decline.
The breakdown.
- Factual basis Multiple wire services published line-by-line fact checks.6/25
- Self-awareness The President called it 'a year that will go down in history.'4/20
- Staff containment The cabinet sat through the falsehoods on camera.8/20
- Recovery attempt None offered.3/15
- Public spectacle The clip of the President with eyes closed circulated by Tuesday night.10/20
Was this dumb enough?
Members can adjust the score. Become a member.